OTTO: A misdelivered prank gift sees a huge box on my doorstep on Christmas Eve—and when a naked man steps out of it, all my Christmas daydreams come true. Maybe I won't spend this holiday season by myself after all.

GRAY: The snowstorm is thick and fast, so I’m stuck at this gorgeous stranger’s house. I’m too embarrassed to admit to my family what delayed me from joining them, so Otto steps in to rescue me again—by pretending to be my boyfriend. Only trouble is, I’d really like him to be my boyfriend for real.

Can we find the best gift of all this Christmas: a future together?